Showing posts with label Fulfilling the Vision. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fulfilling the Vision. Show all posts

Sunday, July 10, 2011

Sangria & Sliders

Sangria and Sliders graphicI attended the Sangria & Sliders event at St. Paul’s this afternoon. It being very hot, the event was held in the lounge, rather than in the lounge and outdoors. That was probably just as well. Other items were available, but the main food provided included dinner-roll-sized hamburgers, sandwiches of pulled-pork or chicken salad, and, of course sangria. Millie Ryan and her husband Gary were responsible for the food, which was very good.

The event was part of the capital campaign, supposedly an opportunity to hear about the campaign and to comment on it. Apparently other gatherings have been held with select parishioners. I was not selected. My guess is that thisCover of brochure event was designed for people like me who were not invited to private meetings but still might be interested in what is being planned. (No one has explained this, so I may be completely wrong.)

A tri-fold brochure was distributed, whose cover can be seen at the left. The entire brochure can be seen here. The brochure doesn’t offer much more than parishioners have been told so far, but Lou’s presentation did give more details.

The official kickoff event for the capital campaign will be October 15, though some people will be solicited for big contributions before then. The celebration for the completion of the campaign will be December 4. Pledges will be sought in parallel with the annual stewardship campaign, though Lou said that the stewardship campaign comes first—no one should reduce a pledge to the stewardship campaign to contribute to the capital campaign. Pledges to the capital campaign will generally be fulfilled over a three-year period.

In the question-and-answer period, air conditioning the church again proved controversial. I asked if the job could really be done for $200,000 and was told yes, that cool air would be piped up through the floor. Some people argued that air conditioning is not needed. Lou, however, said that he thought air conditioning was the most important part of the campaign, that younger people expect a church to be air conditioned. Having church attendance go down in the summer is not a good thing, he added. I’m not sure that air conditioning will keep up attendance in the summer—people do go on vacation—but, basically, I think Lou is right.

I said that parishioners should be given a list of what the $250,000 Property Maintenance Fund was intended to finance. Lou tried to duck this one, saying that unforeseen maintenance needs could not be predicted. I argued that much of what is in the campaign is deferred maintenance that should be funded in our annual budget. I asked when we will begin doing that, and was told that we simply have not had the money in recent years, but we will try to budget adequately for maintenance sometime in the future. What I didn’t say is that if we haven’t had sufficient funds to maintain our physical plant, we should have found the money elsewhere in the budget. If I’m not mistaken, St. Paul’s has a smaller congregation and a larger staff than it has ever had in the nearly quarter century I’ve been at St. Paul’s.

Several comments were made about the $50,000 overhead of the campaign. Lisa Brown said she has been impressed with the woman from the Episcopal Church Foundation who has been working with the church. (ECF gets $30,000 for its assistance.) $6,000 is allocated to “miscellaneous expenses,” including postage and celebrations. Also included in the overhead is $14,000 for the feasibility study done last year. This is confusing to me, as that money was taken out of the Property Fund. If this money is being put back in the property fund, it is funding another $14,000 in maintenance. This needs to be clarified.

I want to mention a couple of specific projects. Lou, for the first time in my memory, suggested that an automatic door opener would be installed on the handicapped restroom. I first identified a problem with the handicapped restroom door more than a year ago. I hope we do put an automatic door opener on the facility, but I would like to see this commitment in black and white.

Finally, I asked about the plan to achieve handicapped access in the front of the church by eliminating the front steps. I said that parishioners need to see an elevation of what this will look like before we approve the plan. I also suggested that the diocese needs to approve the changes, according to Canon XXXI, Section 2:
It shall be the duty of every Parish of the Diocese to lay before this Commission [on Church Architecture] the preliminary sketches of any new Church, Chapel, parish house or rectory, or of proposed changes of importance in any such existent buildings, and no such work of erection or changes shall be undertaken until the plans shall have received the approval of the Commission. The counsel and advice of the Commission shall be given in writing to the parish requesting the same within one calendar month after the receipt of the plans by the said Commission.
Curiously, Lou, who serves with me on the Committee on Constitution and Canons, did not seem aware of this provision.

Monday, June 27, 2011

So You Think You Don’t Know One…

Most of us, if we know anything about the Episcopal Church Foundation (ECF), know that the organization was engaged to do a feasibility study for Fulfilling the Vision. (I understand that ECF has been engaged to help run the latest capital campaign.) ECF does more, however, and it maintains a Web site called ECF Vital Practices. The introduction to this site begins
ECF Vital Practices offers vestry members and other people of faith, resources and tools to respond to the changing needs of the Church. Building upon the spiritually grounded, practical Vestry Papers articles that have inspired and informed vestry members since 1995, Vital Practices uses the Internet to both expand its offering and its audience.
There is a good deal of material on the ECF site relevant to running an Episcopal parish. I must sheepishly admit that I haven’t read much of it, but then I am neither a priest nor a Vestry member. Apparently, a good place to start reading is the home page for the “Vestry Papers” section. The big topics on which you will find essays there include Administration, Buildings and Grounds, Communications, Conflict, Finance, Hospitality, Stewardship, Worship, and others.

One of the essays I found interesting on the site is by the retired Bishop of Maine and former St. Paul’s parishioner from long ago Chilton Knudsen. It is called “So You Think You Don’t Know One….” The essay is about addition, not simply in relation to pastoral care, but in relation to how members of a parish family treat one another. (Knudsen is a conflict mediator and is co-author of So You Think You Don’t Know One? Addiction and Recovery in Clergy and Congregations.) It is no secret, of course, that interactions in some parishes are healthier than in others. Knudsen enumerates unhealthy behavior, among them
  • Lack of transparency, secret-keeping (about many matters in congregational life)
  • A culture of manipulation and power-struggling
  • Image-obsession, relating to buildings, reputation, or prominence of congregation
  • Patterns of ignoring or suppressing new ideas and new possibilities
Likewise, she lists more desirable behavior, such as
  • Truth-telling (without scapegoating)
  • Entering a time of self-examination, in the form of reviews, leadership development, planning, discernment
  • Evaluating current policies and practices, and adopting of new ones
  • Adopting of methods of assuring accountability and mutual responsibility
Depressingly, her first list is longer than her second. The essay nonetheless makes interesting reading. Check it out.

Monday, May 23, 2011

Scaled-back Capital Campaign

The rector and Vestry presented their scaled-back capital campaign proposal at yesterday’s adult forum. The main presentation was done by treasurer Bob Johnston. Bob claimed that parish leaders listened to what parishioners said about Fulfilling the Vision, and there was evidence that that was true. The scope of the coming campaign is more restricted, and the amount of money the parish seeks to raise is substantially smaller than that of the overreaching Fulfilling the Vision. In fact, the campaign is so scaled back, it isn’t even clear that it has a name. The title slide of yesterday’s PowerPoint presentation contained the slogan “Celebrating Our Heritage/Securing Our Future,” but that was juxtaposed to “175th Anniversary of St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, 1836–2011.” In case that slogan was meant to be a name for the campaign, it should be said at the outset that it’s too long. (“Conserving Our Heritage” wouldn’t be such a bad title.)

Principles

Bob Johnston articulated a number of principles for the capital campaign:
  1. The parish will take on no new debt.
  2. Projects will be undertaken on a pay-as-you-go basis.
  3. Costs will be kept as low as possible.
  4. Annual stewardship will remain the parish’s first priority.
These precepts require some explanation and comment. Items (1) and (2) are closely related. In our most recent capital campaigns, we did not quite raise the amount of money we needed to do the work we undertook, and we were required to use loans to complete the projects. (I think our outstanding loan may in part be needed to pay for our organ, which is more than a decade old. It is also paying for parking lot paving, for which we did not even try to raise extra funds.) Whereas some financial people would argue that paying of a $60,000 loan at 3% interest is not a high priority, there is a symbolic value in getting rid of existing debt and reassuring the parish that additional debt will not be assumed. Retiring debt was universally applauded in the Fulfilling the Vision plan.

The pay-as-you-go idea would not be practical for a large, complex project, but this campaign will be funding many relatively small, unconnected projects, so it probably is practical to say that we will fund each activity only after all the funds for it are available.

I find item (3) worrisome. We expect our leaders to be good stewards of the buildings, grounds, and money entrusted to them. We would be upset if the church were to install gold-plated telephones or telephones from the dollar store. On the other hand, I think that few would complain about the purchase of a sterling silver chalice, rather than a silver-plate chalice. A 175-year-old church that expects to be around for a long time can afford neither extravagance nor penny-pinching. I worry that there is penny-pinching going on here in order to assure that this plan comes to fruition. I think that many parishioners would agree that doing the most needed repairs and enhancements well is preferable to doing more work just adequately.

In particular, I am not encouraged by the recently complete (or nearly complete) repair of the steps at the Mayfair Drive entrance to the narthex. I thought the steps should be limestone, not concrete, so they would match the steps at the front of the building and at the lower Mayfair Drive entrance. (See “Construction Progress?”) I’m sure the concrete steps, which I think look awful, were cheaper. We will be living with them for a long time.

Principle (4) has to do with timing. Preliminary work in organizing the capital campaign will begin soon, but actual pledges to the campaign will not be solicited until the fall, at the same time as the annual stewardship campaign. I think Bob was saying that he doesn’t want people to decrease their pledges to fund the capital campaign. The priorities of the Vestry, however, may not be the priorities of parishioners, and running the two campaigns in parallel will necessarily cause people to consider how they want to allocate their contributions to St. Paul’s.

Overview

The only handout at the presentation was this one:

May 22 handout
Bob’s presentation was accompanied by a slide show that, it must be said, added little to what he had to say. (It was telling that the slide show was clearly derived from the PowerPoint presentation used for Fulfilling the Vision. Both presentations pictured the deteriorated steps to the narthex and show the audio equipment in the library to illustrate the church sound system, which is actually behind the high altar. I guess this is an illustration of keeping costs as low as possible.)

As I understand it, the projects identified on the handout are to be funded in the order listed. Thus, for example, no work will be done on the physical plant until the existing debt is paid off. One could quibble both about this procedure and about the ordering of projects, but the overall cost of the proposed projects, $775,000, is only 42% of what Fulfilling the Vision was projected to cost. Raising $775,000 should certainly be possible for St. Paul’s, although the amount is more than the Episcopal Church Foundation estimated that the ambitious Fulfilling the Vision could have raised. I think that parishioners saw Fulfilling the Vision as simply ridiculous, however. The current proposal, though hardly perfect, is both reasonable and practical.

Details

Nevertheless, the devil, as they say, is in the details. The most distressing part of yesterday’s presentation was the lack of important details. The three items labeled “Property Maintenance” are black boxes that the Vestry itself hasn’t yet filled in. These projects simply represent stuff that needs to be done, and someone will figure out just what that stuff is at some unspecified time. I believe that, before anyone is asked to contribute to the new campaign, the contents of those black boxes need to be determined and disclosed. As things now stand, $250,000 (32% of the entire campaign goal) is a blank check. How are parishioners to evaluate priorities when they do not know just what all the projects are? Is there really $175,000 of repairs to the church that are more important than saving our stained glass windows?

I was perhaps most pleased by one item that does not figure into the revised project list—the reconfiguration of the undercroft. I never thought this was a good idea—see “A Proposal for a Capital Campaign”—and spending $100,000 on it was not good stewardship. On the other hand, are we sure this project has been dumped? We need to know what our $250,000 in “property maintenance” is actually going to buy.

I have very mixed feelings about item (3) on the project list. This seems to have made it from Fulfilling the Vision without modification. Some or all of the exterior doors are to be replaced, and electric door openers are to be installed on the exterior door nearest the elevator and, apparently, on one of the front doors. Moreover, the paving in front of the building is to be sloped from the sidewalk to the level of the narthex floor, eliminating the front steps. Parishioners have yet to be shown an elevation of the “improved” church façade, but I think it will look horrible without being very useful. (I say more about this irredeemably bad idea in “A Proposal for a Capital Campaign.” In that same post, I also offer other accessibility projects that no one else seems to have thought of.)

I asked a question about the fact that the projected cost for a new sound system has dropped $25,000 from what was proposed in Fulfilling the Vision. Vestry member Paul Barker gave an explanation that seemed to suggest that the new proposal involves first-rate equipment without “custom” nameplates. He also indicated that some desired functions “can be added later.” St. Paul’s tends not to get around to such enhancements, however, and I fear that the apparent cost savings is part of our keeping costs as low as possible. On the other hand, it is not clear that we need even a $75,000 sound system. It worries me that Paul, who plays in our 8:45 band, answered my question. A sound system to support speech and the choir and one to support a band can be quite different. Does St. Paul’s want to commit to alternative worship styles for the foreseeable future?

I am frankly a bit offended that no one asked me about our audio needs. I am a member of the choir and, for more than 15 years, was Audio-Visual Coördinator at St. Paul’s. Moreover, I was on two committees that studied (and priced) a new sound system. I have concerns both about the audio equipment we actually need and the aesthetic impact new speakers might have on the church. A more general concern is that our parish leadership seems to feel no need to ask parishioners what they want. Nor do our leaders seem inclined to take advantage of the expertise that may exist in our rather talented congregation.

I also asked about the $60,000 for our stained glass. Apparently, we are pinching pennies here as well. I wanted to know if $60,000 was really enough to conserve our windows for the future. Jack Foster, who was not part of the presentation but who had consulted with experts about our windows, indicated that $60,000 would only fund the first phase of a three-phase program to conserve our precious windows. In particular, it would only fund urgent repairs. How soon will we need another capital campaign to make the urgent repairs on the windows we are going to ignore for the present?

I am pleased that we are going to do something about our signage. The slide show was illustrated with our large sign near Washington Road and the brass plaque on the front of the building. Nothing was said about how the signs are to be changed, however. Inquiring minds want to know. Moreover, the overview calls for improvements in both external and internal signage. What signs do we really need to change inside? Are we planning to replace all the signs that say “Undercroft” with signs that say “Parish Hall” or—God forbid!—“Parish Hall/Undercroft”? Again, I suspect that parishioners want to know what they are being asked to pay for. They also want to know that what they are being asked to pay for is reasonable.

Finally, I should say something about the campaign costs. Bob explained that we have already spent $14,000 on the feasibility study that shot down the last capital campaign proposal. The Vestry is suggesting that we restore that money to the Property Fund and pay another $30,000 to the Episcopal Church Foundation for assistance with the campaign. Another $6,000 is to be spent on miscellaneous items such as a grand celebration when we’re done. In other words, we really are putting $264,000 into property maintenance and improvement. In any case, capital campaign costs are listed ninth in the campaign overview. This may be unrealistic. I suspect that the Episcopal Church Foundation will expect to be paid even if we only raise $650,000.

Conclusions

Our scaled-back capital campaign is clearly an improvement over the ill-considered Fulfilling the Vision, but parishioners need to know more than they know now about what the plan really is. (Actually, even the Vestry needs to know more than they know now.) If our own leaders do not recognize the requirement for more information, perhaps our adviser from the Episcopal Church Foundation will bring it up.

Having said that, I must say that I am not yet on board with Son of Fulfilling the Vision. The plan is half-baked, ignores many needs of the parish, and, I expect, will not solicit parishioner opinion in any sincere or effective way. For another take on what a capital fund might support, see my previous post “A Proposal for a Capital Campaign.”

Friday, May 20, 2011

A Proposal for a Capital Campaign

The last time the details of a capital campaign were unveiled at St. Paul’s, parishioners had no advance warning as to what projects were to be proposed. I offered my own analysis of the plan after it was announced, but I would have preferred being better prepared to discuss Fulfilling the Vision at the one and only opportunity the parish was given to do so. (My comments on last year’s proposal can be read beginning with the post “Fulfilling the Vision, Part 1.”)

Presumably, the plan to be presented on Sunday is going to look much like the last plan, less the features to which parishioners most objected, especially the “ministry enhancements” that were priced at $425,000.

Rather than wait until Sunday to comment on the latest plan, I thought it would be an interesting and helpful exercise for me to propose my own plan, which can then be compared to what will actually be presented on Sunday. I don’t have the wherewithal to put costs on each item I think should be funded by a capital campaign, but many of my suggestions will be in the parish’s plan anyway. You’ll have to guess what everything else will cost.

Fulfilling the Vision was actually pretty vague on many points. For example, $100,000 was to be spent on
Miscellaneous painting, repairs throughout: roof, nursery school water damage, improve lighting, improve interior and exterior signage
Because I have not inspected the entire building, I will have to be just as indefinite about some items, but I will try to be as specific as possible.

Guidelines for Inclusion

It is clear that parishioners will only support a fund drive that is restricted to repairs and improvements of our physical plant. Valid projects should make the church more beautiful, more inviting, more functional, more secure, or more efficient. Expensive projects that have only a small payoff or that have undesirable side effects should not be undertaken. (Often, for example, architectural modifications intended to facilitate handicapped access turn into aesthetic disasters, particularly when construction details are chosen primarily on the basis of cost.)

Fulfilling the Vision proposed to pay off the church’s existing debt, an idea that was popular with parishioners but was something of a surprise to the representatives of the Episcopal Church Foundation who did the feasibility study of the aborted campaign. Since then, our debt has been restructured, the parish having borrowed from the Growth Fund at an attractive interest rate. Any capital campaign is likely to require some short-term financing, and paying off our existing debt might require our taking on at least short-term debt at a less attractive rate. Forget paying off the debt for now.

Clearly, much of the aforementioned $100,000 was intended for what can only be described as routine—and, in many cases, deferred—maintenance. St. Paul’s must get into the habit of maintaining its buildings and grounds on a current basis, financed through the normal operating fund. Putting money into a “Facilities Maintenance Fund,” as was proposed last time to the tune of $200,000, is a bad idea in the abstract and looks suspiciously like a scheme to shelter routine expenses from diocesan assessment. I hope that the Facilities Maintenance Fund idea has been dropped, though I expect to see it proposed again on Sunday.

Likewise, neither outreach nor our endowment should have any claim on money raised for capital expenses. Our buildings and grounds are indeed in need of repair and upgrading, and we should focus exclusively on those needs.

A Capital Fund Drive Proposal

Below, I offer my list of worthy projects for St. Paul’s to embrace. I will try to be clear, but I will not attempt to write an essay on each one. For convenience, I will group projects that are somehow related. I will not try to rank the projects in order of desirability. It isn’t important that all parishioners agree on the relative importance of all the tasks to be done; it is only important that we have a general sense that the projects we essay are worthy ones.

The order in which I list projects (or even categories of projects) is arbitrary. Moreover, I make no claim that I have thought of everything. I may have missed some significant undertakings or suggested others that might be done differently. My goal is simply to offer a checklist for evaluating what will be offered to parishioners on May 22. It is my hope, though not my expectation, that parishioners will be given a chance to modify what is being proposed.

Accessibility. Put electric door openers on the door to the parking lot near the elevator and on the handicapped rest room. The door on the rest room is very hard to open, particularly if you are in a wheelchair.

Provide an awning at the door to the parking lot near the elevator. This would be very helpful in inclement weather. This need not be a permanent part of the building. (I don’t know the best way to provide shelter here.)

Add a ramp or lift to the chancel near the sacristy. The chancel is one of the areas of the building currently inaccessible to the handicapped. This would allow handicapped/wheelchair access to the chancel. I suspect that the existing stairs could be replaced with a ramp. (The balcony is also not handicapped accessible, but there is little we can do about that.)

Replace the stairs to the choir room with a ramp. This is tricky but doable. (The choir room is another area within the building not handicapped accessible.)

Provide a ramp from the door near the financial secretary’s office to St. Margaret’s garden. The steps can be replaced with the ramp. There is currently no handicapped access to the garden.

There is at least one place in the church where a wheelchair can be conveniently placed during a service or other event. We should create a few more by shortening pews.

Security. Replace any external doors that need to be replaced. (This may be most of them.)

Re-key all the locks in the building, so that there are not so many keys required and there is a master key (and, perhaps, sub-masters). It might be helpful to have an external door with programmable keys, so that temporary keys (or key codes) could be distributed for specific events. (If I have a need to enter the building to prepare for an event, I could be granted access for that day only, for example.)

It is not clear that security cameras are needed at St. Paul’s, but their use should be considered.

Maintenance. Repair water damage and repaint as necessary. Make whatever permanent changes are needed to prevent future damage. (I understand that there is water damage in the chapel and perhaps in the nursery school.) The old sacristy next to the storage area at the end of the undercroft is very damp, which threatens the material stored there. This should also be fixed.

Repair and stabilize our stained glass. There are broken panes, and it may be time to reset all of the glass. St. Paul’s has lovely stained glass, and we should do all we can to conserve it.

There are, no doubt, other painting and wall repair to be done, as well as other minor maintenance projects.

If the roof needs repair, by all means repair it.

Comfort. Air condition the church. I realize that this is controversial, but, in 21st-century America, people expect their churches to be comfortable.

Air condition the kitchen. How could we not have done this before?

Air condition the choir room. There is currently a room air conditioner in the choir room. It is nearly useless and rather noisy.

Replace the deteriorating choir chairs in the chancel. Besides being in poor repair, the chairs have a distressing tendency to fall over backwards. When the chancel was renovated and the new organ installed, there was never a plan for how the choir was to be accommodated. We are using chairs predating the renovation.

Develop and execute a plan for seating in the balcony. Even less planning was done for the balcony when the organ was installed. It’s obvious, and it’s embarrassing.

Exterior and Grounds. The stonework of St. Margaret’s garden is in a poor state of repair. We should fix it.

We should hire a landscape architect to develop a master plan for the grounds and begin implementing that plan.

The sidewalk immediately in front of the main doors is in bad repair. I would like to see the area expanded to become a gathering area for events such as the Palm Sunday service. I wrote about this and about the plan to provide handicapped access to the front door in my post “Fulfilling the Vision, Part 4.” For a number of reasons, I am now opposed to the idea of eliminating the front steps and sloping the paving in front of the church from the sidewalk to the level of the narthex floor. There are many reasons for my opposition. The main reason is aesthetic, but the idea of dropping off the handicapped on Washington Road has its own set of problems. After much consideration, I find little reason to provide a handicapped entrance to the narthex. After all, most people, whether handicapped or not, enter the building from the parking lot. There is reason to provide a handicapped exit from the narthex, however, as, in case of fire, someone in a wheelchair, say, will not have access to the elevator. A ramp could be built from the narthex door facing Mayfair Drive, but I don’t have a favorite plan for this. We need an architect’s help here.

Re-engineer our outdoor sign, which is not a good advertisement for the church. (See my post “Welcome, If You’re Going South.”) We long ago gave up changing our sign with any regularity. The interior of the sign is deteriorated, the lock on one side is broken, and only one side of the sign is lit. On the other hand, the frame of the sign is quite handsome. I would like to see the sign rehabilitated and its innards replaced with an electronic sign, as is becoming common for churches to use. Such a sign can be updated from inside the building. Mt. Lebanon may give us grief about such a sign, but the fight is worth fighting, as it is the only kind of sign that really can be read from a passing car. Our outdoor banners are tacky, cannot be easily updated, and seem to come loose from their moorings with alarming frequency.

Redesign or replace the brass sign on the front of the church. This brass plate has service times on it from many years ago and a place for the rector’s name. The sign should have the church’s name and the dates when it was founded and when it moved to its present location, and nothing else. That information will never change.

Clean the external building surface by whatever means.

Functional Improvements. Wire the entire building for Internet service and provide WiFi throughout the building.

Add electrical outlets outside the front and rear of the building. These would be useful in a variety of circumstances.

Replace all two-wire outlets with three-wire outlets. Two-wire outlets remain in the church (and perhaps elsewhere). This is inconvenient (and potentially hazardous) when one needs to power a device with a three-wire plug.

Install a completely new sound system. Suggesting this makes me very nervous, as I am afraid we will choose a sound system oriented toward use of a church band rather than an organ and choir and the spoken word. Parishioners should ask hard questions about what is to be installed and how obtrusive that might be, either sonically or visually.

Install wireless microphones in the undercroft.

Improve ability to aim fixtures in the church and replace lamps. Some of the spotlights in the church that are high off the floor are unusable now because the fixtures are mis-aimed. They are difficult to adjust, and it is difficult to replace the lamps when they burn out. Some fixtures need to be replace, and it may be useful to replace them with fixtures with motors that rotate them. It may even be practical to add cat walks to make it easier to replace lamps and adjust fixtures.

Replace the piano in the undercroft.

Efficiency Improvements. The church uses many lamps that are power-hungry or expensive. New technologies are becoming available that will allow us to light the building at much lower cost.

Aesthetic Improvements. The lanterns in the chancel should be replaced with lanterns that match the majority of chandeliers in the church. These will have to be custom made, but the “witch’s hat” lanterns are both ugly and dangerous, as they encourage heat buildup that melts the wiring insulation.

Provide better lighting in the sanctuary area. The lighting in this area was never revisited after the cantilevered organ chests were added. The exposed organ pipes are now a major architectural feature of the church, yet they are poorly lit, and the areas under them are lit even worse.

Additional lighting should also be provided for the antiphonal organ. Again, a significant architectural feature is being insufficiently highlighted.

Add additional down light toward the rear of the nave. In the last building campaign, down lights toward the back of the nave were deleted from the project due to a misunderstanding between the church and the contractor. The rear of the church remains darker than the front.

Construct some kind of partition at the front of the (liturgically) south transept to hide sound equipment and instruments when not in use. I don’t know if St. Paul’s will continue to have a band, but, as long as it does, we seem to have created an unsightly mess in the transept. Since we cannot reasonably put all the instruments somewhere else during services in which they are not being used, let’s at least hide them.

Lighten the stain of the remaining dark wood in the church. This includes the doors to the narthex, some baseboard, and the front balcony wall, which may actually have to be replaced.

Final Thoughts

This is, I think, a substantial list.

Notice that I have not advocated spending $100,000 to reconfigure the undercroft. I have not heard a credible argument that doing so, which will reduce the amount of usable space in the undercroft, is either wise or cost-effective.

If we do go forward with a capital campaign, I hope that parishioners will have some say both in what projects are a part of the campaign and just how those projects are executed. If parishioners have no say in just what the campaign is going to fund, I suggest that they do not fund the campaign at all.

Friday, May 13, 2011

Gird Your Loins for Fulfilling the Vision II

This week’s e-mail newsletter from St. Paul’s announced that, after the 8:45 service on May 22, there will be “an important informational meeting concerning St. Paul’s Capital Campaign.” Prepare for Fulfilling the Vision II.

This is what parishioners have been told:
You will learn how the Vestry has responded to the opinions and concerns you expressed in last year’s feasibility study, and the plans for a more modest Capital Campaign focusing on much needed improvements and maintenance throughout the church. Come to listen, learn, and have your questions answered.
In fact, the Vestry has voted (1) to go ahead with a capital campaign, and (2) to take the purchase of 28 Mayfair Drive off the table. I suspect that the new, “more modest” capital drive will look much like Fulfilling the Vision, with deletions. The brick-and-mortar portion of that proposal cost $730,000. It will be interesting to see if other items have been added to the campaign or if the items proposed last year have been modified at all.

Significantly, the meeting on the 22nd is “informational.” I assume that means that we will again be told what the campaign is going to be, and we will have no opportunity to question exactly what it is we are being asked to pay for. Even if that is the case, it would be helpful for parishioners to have information about the proposal in advance of the May 22 meeting, so they can ask meaningful questions or express carefully considered opinions. Like the last presentation on a capital campaign, however, this one is likely to be depending on shock and awe.

Saturday, April 23, 2011

Construction Progress?

Easter worshipers who don’t enter the church from the undercroft will find that repairs to the Mayfair entrance to the narthex are complete, or nearly so. Pouring the concrete for the walkways Mayfair entrance to narthexhad been delayed by rain, but a slight break in the weather Thursday allowed the last major task to be completed. The nearly completed project can be seen at the right. (Click on this and other photos for larger images.)

The repair is, I think, only a partial success. The narthex entrance facing Mayfair Drive is, or soon will be, once again usable. The barrels, yellow tape, and other signs of construction will soon be but a memory. The new sidewalk is a good match for the paving in front of the church, which is not run-of-the-mill concrete.

Front stepsThat the new paving matches the old is positive, of course, but the pristine appearance of the new concrete only emphasizes the poor condition of the older sidewalk, which is uneven, cracked, and pockmarked.

The big problem, however, is that the new steps themselves look like they belong on some other building. I objected long before the steps were poured, arguing that it was a mistake to build concrete steps, rather than limestone ones, as are used at the Washington Road and lower Mayfair Drive entrances. (See picture of main entrance at left. The steps have weathered differently from the walls, but they are clearly made of the same material.) The construction drawings that appeared in the undercroft last year—see “Good News/Bad News—called for the replacement steps to be concrete, with a broom finish, and tinted “to match lower building stone color.” Perhaps the result would have been more acceptable if these instructions actually had been followed, but, as constructed, the steps seem tinted to match the brown tone of the sidewalk, rather than the gray tone of the limestone building.

Side stepsThe picture to the left shows just how jarring is the juxtaposition of the new steps and the building proper. Did the contractor make a monumental error? Did someone at St. Paul’s approve a tint that is highly inappropriate? I have no idea.

In any case, I have long thought that too much responsibility rests with the Junior Warden. St. Paul’s used to have a Property Commission that allowed for parishioner ideas and opinions to be factored into maintenance, repair, and improvement decisions. That commission, like others at St. Paul’s, no longer functions to engage ordinary parishioners and benefit from their ideas and, in many cases, their expertise.

This is particularly worrisome, as the Vestry, at its last meeting, decided to move forward with another attempt at running a capital campaign. This time, there will be no money collected for salaries. It is likely that the same set of brick-and-mortar projects will be proposed as last time—the wrong set, I believe—and the possibility of buying the house at 28 Mayfair Drive will be thrown into the mix for good measure. (See “Fulfilling the Vision, Part 1” and subsequent posts about the last proposal for a “capital campaign.”)

Had I been on the Property Commission considering the repair of the Mayfair steps, I would have asked what our ultimate plans were for the front and side lawns of the building. It would have made sense to consider handicapped access for the front of the church, altered signage, and other related issues. (See “Fulfilling the Vision, Part 4.”) That choices were made concerning the Mayfair entrance to the Narthex with little parishioner consultation and little thought for the future—even implementing the access plan proposed in Fulfilling the Vision would require some demolition of what has just been built—does not lead me to believe that I want the same folks making judgments about how to repair and “improve” St. Paul’s physical plant.

Update, 5:00 PM: I stopped by the church this afternoon and noticed that the new sidewalk does not closely match the existing concrete. It does have visible gravel, but it is lighter in color. When I took the pictures above, it was raining, and the concrete was wet.

Thursday, March 10, 2011

House Tour

Lou took attendees at Tuesday’s staff meeting on a tour of a house directly across Mayfair Drive from St. Paul’s. He suggested that the parish could buy the house and convert it to meeting rooms, space for the youth program, or, unbelievably, a rectory. The house could be financed from a capital campaign to be launched this summer. The house can be seen below. (Sorry about the photograph. It was taken during heavy rain, and the lot is rather overgrown.)

St. Paul’s Annex?

Commentary

The idea of buying one of the houses adjacent to St. Paul’s has several times been considered by the Vestry. Obviously, the Vestry has not hitherto approved such a proposal. Probably what the church needs most is office space and storage space, and a nearby house could provide that. I have personally advocated such a purchase when nearby real estate has come on the market. I suspect the Vestry has not acted in these circumstances either because there was not a clear plan for what the church would do with a house or because it wasn’t obvious how to fund such a purchase.

I am told that the church has been given five months to make an offer on the house in question. My suspicion is that the owners came to the church. Selling to St. Paul’s could be attractive in a bad real estate market, in which buyers might be hard to find. But is the purchase a good move for the church?

It is difficult to see how. To begin with, stone houses in Mt. Lebanon do not come cheap. Whatever state the property is in—there is reason to believe the house is not in a good state of repair—it would need to be renovated to serve whatever role we assigned to it, and we would likely have to spend a good deal to bring it into code compliance as a public building by adding things like sprinklers. Even with a good deal of renovation, it is difficult to see how the building could be made handicapped accessible. It is a multi-story house whose entrance is a good deal higher than street level. We could easily spend half a million dollars and still not have a convenient or handicapped-accessible building.

Even if we had half a million dollars in hand, this looks like a solution in search of a problem. Does Lou really not have a plan, or does he have a plan he is simply not telling us? (The latter seems more likely.) He told the staff meeting that half the parishes in The Episcopal Church have rectories. That may have once been true, but I doubt it is any more. The Church Pension Fund has long recommended against parish rectories, and many of those properties that have not been sold off are being occupied by renters unrelated to the parish landlords. I know a lot of local parishes that have sold their rectories but not many with existing rectories. Cynthia Bronson-Sweigert has moved out of Redeemer’s rectory, which she thought too small. St. Andrew’s has converted its rectory into meeting space, though the upper floor is not in use because the parish did not have the money to bring it up to code.

In any case, buying a nearby house may not be the only way for the parish to get more space. Some storage could be had off-site. We might even be able to build over the parking lot. Such alternatives should be considered along with the purchase of adjacent real estate. Are we, in fact, using the space we have effectively?

Rather more disturbing is that Lou’s capital campaign, as we knew it would, is again rearing its ugly head. Surely, the real message from the Episcopal Church Foundation was that not only did the parish not like certain aspects of Fulfilling the Vision, but that the parish had issues that had to be dealt with before embarking on such a campaign. Whatever you may think of the emotional health of the parish, however, we appear to be unable to fully finance even our payroll, much less make necessary repairs to our building. (With all the rain, water has been leaking into the chapel, by the way.) Surely the building we already own needs to take precedence over renovation of a building we might buy.

It is time for St. Paul’s to take a serious look at the state of the parish. The visioning we did a year and a half ago was a sham. Real engagement by the members of the parish is required. We need to start over, developing a realistic vision for the future—a vision owned by parishioners, not simply by the rector.

Thursday, September 30, 2010

Copyediting

Children’s Ministry brochureWhen Glenn Holliman of Episcopal Church Foundation delivered the bad news that Fulfilling the Vision would not fly—see “Fulfilling the Vision Postponed”—he worked hard at putting the best face on the news. Among other things, Holliman complimented the parish on its newly released Children’s Ministry brochure. I had seen this brochure only the day before, but I picked one up only after I heard Holliman’s comments. Only today have I gotten around to actually reading it.

So, was the praise justified? Well, yes and no. The cross with the hand prints on the cover is certainly arresting, and carrying the hand print motif through much of the brochure does, I think, work. Overall, so does the Berlin Sans FB font, although the Berlin Sans FB Demi Bold used in the calendar is ugly and hard to read. Ideally, the brochure should have been printed on heavier stock.

Then, there is the text. For years, I have complained that publications from St. Paul’s are poorly edited and proofread. This brochure is no exception. The first line of body text includes the name “St. Paul’ Episcopal Church.” I kid you not; the “s” is indeed missing! Without getting picky, I identified:
  • 1 missing letter
  • 24 missing commas
  • 1 missing period
  • 1 missing capital
  • 1 extraneous word that was clearly intended to be deleted
  • 5 missing spaces
  • 1 missing hyphen
  • 2 misstatements of fact
  • 4 badly chosen phrases
  • 1 instance of failing to use italics
  • 1 arguable misspelling (“worshipping” is a British, not an American spelling)
  • 1 single quotation mark where a double quotation mark was called for
  • 1 misspelling
That last item is interesting. On the back page is a list titled “The Top 10 Reasons Why Children are Welcome in Church.” At the bottom of the page, Tracey E. Herzer is credited with the list. (The list is found here.) That list is, in fact, the source of “worshipping,” so this error can perhaps be excused. On the other hand, there is little excuse for copying “quiet” as “quite.” Was the text copied and pasted, or was it actually retyped (and retyped badly)?

I have a reputation as an obsessive editor. Am I being unfair in insisting on professional standards in publications from St. Paul’s? I don’t know. Are we only an amateur church?

Sunday, September 19, 2010

Trust

Today’s Gospel reading about the dishonest manager certainly is a perplexing one, and I’m not sure Mabel’s sermon this morning made its message clearer. Perhaps my thoughts were diverted, however, by Mabel’s assertion that the recent feasibility report on Fulfilling the Vision from the Episcopal Church Foundation (ECF) suggests that St. Paul’s parishioners are not quite ready to trust—read take on a $1.83 million fund-raising campaign—given what Calvary rector Harold Lewis refers to as the “recent unpleasantness” in our diocese.

I believe the ECF report exaggerates the effect of the diocesan schism on St. Paul’s, and I think Mabel further exaggerates what was said in the report. The report states, for example,
  • This schism rippled through St. Paul’s and numerous long-term members left, again depleting energies and good will. Church membership and stewardship have suffered as a result.
In fact, St. Paul’s lost remarkably few members as a result of Bob Duncan’s depredations, and which camp the parish would end up in was never really in doubt, even if parish leaders waited painfully long to declare the obvious. Whatever loss of membership there has been in recent years—see “Is St. Paul’s Growing?”—has largely been due to other factors. Trust may indeed be in short supply at St. Paul’s, but the ECF report uses the word “trust” only once, and not in the context of diocesan schism.

There is much that can be blamed on Bob Duncan, but the leadership of St. Paul’s must take responsibility for the failure of the Fulfilling the Vision proposal to gain traction. The proposal was a bad plan that was ill-timed and poorly promoted. If the parish could not put its trust in the plan that was advanced, it had good reason for not doing so.

I fear that Fulfilling the Vision II—be assured that there will be another proposal, of whatever name, coming down the pike—will simply drop the more ridiculous aspects of the first proposal while failing yet again to solicit parishioner input as to priorities and objectives. The small group of people who completed the Vision 15 work clearly did not capture the sentiments of the parish as a whole, and continuing to rely on Vision 15 to guide the parish will only further alienate the majority that finds it difficult to take Vision 15 seriously.

I will have more to say about how parishioners should be consulted on certain matters in a future post.

Let me conclude by noting that St. Paul’s, despite an explicit promise by Lou to put the ECF report on the parish Web site, has not yet made the ECF report available to parishioners in electronic form. My guess is that few members have gone to the office to read it. Poor communications within the parish, a concern identified long before Lou arrived, continues to plague St. Paul’s.

Friday, September 10, 2010

Good News/Bad News

The good news is that repairs have begun on the sidewalk and steps leading to the Mayfair Drive entrance to the narthex. The bad news is that we may not be doing a good job of the repair.Plans for steps

Last Sunday, I saw plans for the repairs posted, without comment, in the undercroft. (See picture at right, and click on it for a much larger image.) The plans call for replacing the steps more or less as they have been. The steps are to be concrete. The plans were marked “OWNER/REVIEW SET/NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION,” which I took to mean that demolition and construction were not imminent. I learned yesterday, however, that this was a misinterpretation; I passed the church and discovered that the existing steps have already been demolished. (See below.)

I have two concerns: the materials called for and whether we are ultimately planning to provide handicapped access at the front of the building.
Upper Mayfair Drive entrance on 9/10/2010
All of St. Paul’s is faced with limestone. The front steps and the lower Mayfair entrance steps are limestone. The upper Mayfair steps, that is, the steps just demolished, were mostly concrete. (From the rubble pile, it seems that there was some limestone used. The deteriorated steps were definitely concrete, however. See picture below of the steps as of sometime last May.) The existing stone steps are largely in good repair, except that there are significant cracks where railings were installed. (I suspect that none of the iron railings are original.) In any case, I believe the integrity of the building demands limestone steps. I was told Sunday, however, that limestone cost too much. Shouldn’t it be parishioners, or at least the Vestry, who decide this? (I am told that the Vestry has not been shown the plans or approved the project.)

It is clear from the recent feasibility report on Fulfilling the Vision that parishioners are very concerned about the physical plant of St. Paul’s, and I suspect that they might well opt for limestone steps if asked, even if such steps were more expensive than concrete ones. No one has asked, however, which seems to have become the way business is conducted at St. Paul’s these days.

The second issue is whether we are going to provide handicapped access at the front of the building. I suggested back in May—see “Do We Really Want to Repair the Steps”—that we could use the excuse of repairing the steps to the narthex to provide handicapped access via a ramp from Mayfair Drive. Stairs last MayThe plan for Fulfilling the Vision—now on hold, of course—proposed an alternative plan that would have sloped the pavement in front of the building upward to provide handicapped access from Washington Road. (See “Fulfilling the Vision, Part 1.”) The plans for the present repair connects the front pavement to the Mayfair entrance exactly as it has been. But what if we alter the pavement in front of the building? (It is in poor condition in any case, and a good case could be made for replacing it.) I question whether we should carry out any project involving access to the narthex before we have a comprehensive plan for the front of the church. Because the appearance of the building is affected, that plan should be one at least presented to parishioners, if not actually endorsed by them.

Do we need handicapped access to the narthex? Whenever I bring up the subject, I am told that that is what the elevator is for. After all, we wisely spent the money necessary for an elevator that reaches every level of the church, save for the choir room and chancel. (One might ask for a sign pointing down Mayfair and labeled “Parking and Handicapped Access” or some such, by the way.) One must admit, though, that there is something symbolic in everyone’s being able to enter the church at the front. The parking lot entrance for the handicapped seems a bit like a back-door entrance for “colored.” (I grew up in the South.) Perhaps a more compelling argument for accessibility, however, is for a handicapped exit. In case of fire, the elevator should not be used. What is someone in a wheelchair supposed to do if there is no exit without stairs?

That said, neither plan for handicapped access to the narthex is without its problems. A ramp from Mayfair Drive would have to be long if it were not to be too steep. Access from Washington Road as proposed in Fulfilling the Vision would have significantly changed the building’s façade. Moreover, Washington Road is not an ideal place to discharge passengers, particularly handicapped ones, from an automobile. Even if we installed some sort of driveway in front of the building, the lack of parking would be problematic, particularly for handicapped drivers. The only good solution I see to this problem would be to provide handicapped-only parking parallel to the street but cutting into the existing sidewalk and lawn. Such parking would need to be without a curb to facilitate egress from vehicles.

My current idea for providing handicapped access in front of the church would indeed add a parking area off Washington Road as I have described. I would build a larger paved plaza in front of the church, leaving the front steps as they are. I would build a ramp from that plaza to the side door of the narthex. As it happens, the existing sidewalk from the front of the church to the side entrance actually slopes downward; we had more steps on the side than in the front. This sidewalk could be regraded to go upward. This plan, of course, would require demolition of much of what is about to be built.

Sunday, September 5, 2010

Executive Summary of Feasibility Study Report

“Copies of a summary of the Episcopal Church Foundation Feasibility Study Report are available in the parish office and in the parish hall/undercroft. The summary consists of excerpts of the key findings made by the Episcopal Church Foundation concerning the proposed capital campaign.” That was the announcement at the bottom of the page in today’s bulletin. That summary, and the report it summarizes, are still not on the church’s Web site, but you can read the summary here and the full report here.

As explained in the summary itself, the document “is taken from the ECF report without editorial comment.” This was a wise decision, though, as I noted in “The Episcopal Church Foundation Feasibility Study Report,” the foundation went out of its way to mitigate the sting of its conclusions. Those excuses are reproduced in the executive summary as item 4 under “Concerns.”

Friday, September 3, 2010

Update Needed

St. Paul’s plaqueThe Fulfilling the Vision proposal included a number of building improvements that were widely anticipated, such as repairing the steps at the Mayfair entrance to the narthex. It did not—not explicitly, anyway—include other maintenance and enhancement projects that many of us would like to see. (See, for example, my post “Fulfilling the Vision, Part 2.”) While taking pictures of the banners on the front lawn yesterday—see “Lawn Signs”—I was reminded that there is a bronze plaque on the front of the building that needs updating.

A number of people have mentioned to me that we have never inserted a nameplate into the bronze tablet for our current rector. There is clearly more wrong with it than that, however. Our forebears realized that the parish rector would change from time to time, but they apparently failed to recognize that services and service times might also change. Such details are not cast in stone and should therefore never be cast in bronze.

It should be obvious—was it not obvious to the capital campaign committee?—that our bronze tablet needs to be fixed, and not by chiseling off the text as was seemingly attempted in the past. No, I’m afraid we need professional help. It may be that our current plaque is hopeless, and a new one will have to be manufactured, but I would hope that we could modify what we have, if only for tradition’s sake. (Admittedly, one could make a case for a new plaque that leaves off the rector entirely. The rector changes but the Lord abides.)

I suspect that the COMMUNION, MORNING PRAYER, and CHURCH SCHOOL lines can be removed by a foundry. The space between the two horizontal rules will then need to be filled with something. I suggest adding a bronze medallion in the space, either of the St. Paul’s dove or of the Episcopal Church shield. In the latter case, the medallion can perhaps be painted or enameled.

Wednesday, September 1, 2010

Vestry Delivers the News

The Vestry has now sent its statement responding to the feasibility study report on Fulfilling the Vision to parishioners on the church’s e-mail distribution list. (See posts “Fulfilling the Vision Postponed” and “The Episcopal Church Foundation Feasibility Report.”) The statement is not on the St. Paul’s Web site, but those who did not receive a personal copy can read it on the Constant Contact Web site. (Constant Contact is the e-mail distribution service used by St. Paul’s. An image of the Constant Contact page is shown at the left.)

Alas, the statement does not suggest that the Vestry has any regrets for having handled this matter poorly. We are told, however, that it “ will take the time necessary to revise and refine the various aspects of a capital campaign to focus on those items of greatest interest and concern to the congregation, and then explain more fully the need and rationale for each of them.” This is all well and good, but it is not clear that the Vestry really intends to consult parishioners in any effective way before presenting yet another take-it-or-leave it package. The congregation as a whole needs to be involved in charting our future.

More disappointing is the news that the church “will be providing a summary of the feasibility study report in the near future,” but not yet. “A copy of the full report is available to be read in the parish office.”

Why is there no copy of the report on the parish Web site? Why is the message from the Vestry not on the parish Web site?

In case you missed it, the report is available here. It is a quick and informative read. Don’t wait for the executive summary or the promised report on the Web site. Read it now!

The Episcopal Church Foundation Feasibility Study Report

While the rector and Vestry struggle at getting their story straight, I thought it would be helpful if parishioners could begin reading the capital campaign feasibility study from the Episcopal Church Foundation for themselves. The PDF file available here differs slightly from the paper copy distributed at Monday’s Vestry meeting. (See “Fulfilling the Vision Postponed.”) I believe the differences are only cosmetic, however. The paper copy that was yanked from my hands at the Vestry meeting—very few bound copies were printed, and Vestry members had a stronger claim than I—had a nice cover and the St. Paul’s prospectus in the appendix, both lacking here. The pages may have been formatted slightly differently; this version seems a few pages longer. (I still don’t have a paper copy to compare.) I’m sure the text is the same, however.

The purpose of providing the report here, of course, is to let parishioners make their own judgments about Fulfilling the Vision and the way it has been dealt with by our parish leaders. I cannot avoid making a few observations, however.

What most stands out in this report is the rather strong support for maintaining the building—there is less support for “enhancing” it—and the nearly total lack of support for program expansion financed in any way other than through annual giving. There is also great skepticism that St. Paul’s can raise anything near the price tag of the proposal presented to the congregation, a matter on which ECF agrees.

What is also apparent is that there is deep dissatisfaction among parishioners concerning the state of the parish and little agreement with respect to the details of the Fulfilling the Vision proposal. Whereas the ECF report does not try to hide these unpleasant realities, it struggles to mitigate their significance. According to the ECF, the economy is bad, taxes are worrisome, the split in the diocese was traumatic, previous rectors were poor administrators, parishioners haven’t adapted to the rector’s leadership style. ECF seems to be flattering those who pay its fee. The reality, however, is that Fulfilling the Vision was ill-conceived and poorly sold.

But don’t take my word for it. Read the actual report here. I invite your comments below. Note that you need a Google, AIM, Wordpress, or other ID to leave a comment.

Monday, August 30, 2010

Fulfilling the Vision Postponed

I have only just returned from a long Vestry meeting at which the feasibility report for Fulfilling the Vision prepared by the Episcopal Church Foundation (ECF) was presented. Glenn Holliman, representing ECF, walked the vestry through the 76-page report. Based on that report and presentation, the Vestry has decided to postpone any capital campaign, probably for at least six months or so.

Holloman made clear that there was much support for projects involving St. Paul’s physical plant, but that there was a general consensus that the program part of the proposed initiative should be financed through the annual budget. Even some of the improvements to the building were controversial, particularly the air conditioning of the church, a new sound system, and changes to the undercroft. In any case, it was made clear that the church could not now raise anything near the $1.8 million in the Fulfilling the Vision proposal, both because of concerns about the proposed projects and because of the unfavorable economic climate.

The consensus on the Vestry was that no definitive decision about a capital campaign could be made immediately, but it was recognized that, if the Vestry did not move forward immediately, the campaign would have to be postponed. A statement to the effect that the proposal for a capital campaign will have to be revisited is to be drawn up and presented to parishioners.

The ECF report did not include an executive summary, and it may be up to the Vestry to draft one for the parish. In any case, the ECF report will be made available to parishioners in various forms and will presumably be posted on the parish Web site soon.

I will probably have more to say about tonight’s meeting later, but it is worth noting that the Vestry handled what was no doubt seen by many as bad news with equanimity and maturity. By the time the church undertakes its next capital campaign—I have no doubt that it will eventually—it is to be hoped that there is a greater consensus about what is to be done with the funds raised. The Vestry has a good deal of work to do between now and then.

Meanwhile, the church needs to run a successful stewardship campaign. If the programmatic elements originally proposed for Fulfilling the Vision are ever to be implemented, they will have to be incorporated into the operating budget and financed through increased annual giving.

I hope that the leaders at St. Paul’s will work diligently to build consensus around components of a revised capital campaign, one targeted to physical plant rehabilitation and improvement. It is to be hoped that such a campaign is one that most parishioners can get behind.

Important Vestry Meeting Tonight

St. Paul’s’ Vestry meets tonight at 7 PM in the conference room. Two matters feature prominently on the agenda: the feasibility report on Fulfilling the Vision from the Episcopal Church Foundation (ECF), and preparations for the initiation of the Refuge service set to begin next month.

Indications are that the feasibility report will be something less than a glowing endorsement of the Fulfilling the Vision project, but I, along with most members of the Vestry, have not yet seen it. A presentation will be given by ECF’s Glenn Holloman, whom many parishioners met when he was interviewing people at the church.

It should be an interesting meeting. I will have more to say about it tonight or tomorrow. Stay tuned.

Thursday, August 26, 2010

Is St. Paul’s Growing?

Apparently not.

The figure below is from the Web site of The Episcopal Church. (You can generate graphs for St. Paul’s or for other parishes from here. Click on the figure for a larger view.)



The figure shows three measures of parish size over time. I should hasten to add that none of these measures, and probably no combination of them, measures parish health. (For a provocative essay on measuring parish health, see “Measuring productivity in the church.”)

Of the measures shown here, “Worship Attendance,” usually labeled “Average Sunday Attendance” (ASA) is usually cited as the best indication of the effective size of a parish measured in numbers of people. Church “members” who never show up may be indifferent, alienated, relocated, or dead. Who knows? ASA is both more meaningful and more obvious than many other measures, even to those not actually counting heads or poring over statistics. Income measures, on the other hand, reflect the health of the community as much as they do the size or health of the parish.

So what of St. Paul’s? Anyone who has been around for a decade or more will probably say that St. Paul’s is shrinking. From the chart, it is clear that ASA in the recent past peaked in 1999, was stable for two more years, and then began a steady, if not completely monotonic, decline. The ASA for 2009 (not shown on the chart) was 317, down 3 from the year before. Between 2003 and 2009, ASA varied within the range of 316 ±25. I suspect that the figures I am using do not account for the Saturday evening service, but anyone who has been going to that service knows that it is attracting fewer worshipers than it used to.

Interesting though these facts are, they become more significant in light of Lou’s recent message about adding staff. (See “A Response to the Latest Plea for Fulfilling the Vision.”) The size of the staff at St. Paul’s has been growing and is as big as it has been in two decades. At other times we have been without an associate rector, without a youth director, missing other key staff members, or getting by with temporary replacements. We had more people attending services then.

What’s wrong with this picture? In fact, what’s wrong with St. Paul’s? Do we really expect that a $1.8 million fund drive will fix it? I don’t.

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

A Response to the Latest Plea for Fulfilling the Vision

I have just received The Messenger for September. It includes a half-page essay by Lou concerning Fulfilling the Vision:
As of this writing, we are awaiting the results of the Feasibility Study conducted by the Episcopal Church Foundation. We are grateful for everyone who participated via interview, focus group, or survey questionnaire. Everyone’s views are important, and all will be taken into account. A representative of the Episcopal Church Foundation will report to the Vestry and Capital Campaign Committee on August 30. Based on the results and recommendations of the study, your parish leadership will make decisions concerning whether and when to proceed with the capital campaign, and, assuming we have a campaign, the financial goal, the components of the campaign, and the priorities for funding.

Preliminary feedback indicates that while many parishioners support much of the “brick and mortar” proposals to maintain or enhance our church property, some have questioned the need for the other components relating to pastoral care, outreach, mission, and ministry. I urge everyone to consider that the proposed capital campaign has been developed to make our Vision and Mission as expressed in Vision 15 a reality. All of the proposed projects are interrelated, and all designed to grow the Kingdom of God and do more of Christ’s work, through St. Paul’s. If we put all of our energy and money into enhancing the building, we forget that the Church is the people, not the building. And we run the risk of ultimately having a beautiful but empty building.

Some have also questioned why some of the components, particularly the one for children, youth, young adults, and families have funding for staff. While it is true that staff funding is normally provided through the annual operating budget, this is a chicken/egg dilemma. It is a principle of congregational development that churches need to hire staff in order to grow, and that increased giving should follow. So the rational [sic] for this component of the potential capital campaign is to provide for three to four years of transitional funding, with the operating budget gradually increasing so that the positions could be fully funded by the operating budget after several years. As we grow our programs of great pastoral care, outreach, and activities for children, youth, young adults, families, singles, and seniors, we will attract more people of all ages. The congregation will grow, and the operating budget will increase as the number of contributors increases.

Stay tuned for more information about the Capital Campaign!


The Rev. Lou Hays
(I have reproduced the essay here, since the issue is not yet on the St. Paul’s Web site.)

This essay offers, in order, the following facts and assertions:
  1. The Episcopal Church Foundation (ECF) will report on the feasibility study on August 30.
  2. Initial feedback suggests that there is much resistance to the non-capital components of the proposed project.
  3. All the proposed projects are related and are designed “to make our Vision and Mission as expressed in Vision 15 a reality.”
  4. We should not attend to our building and ignore our people.
  5. The increase in staff will lead to growth and increased giving. After a few years, salaries for new staff will come from increased giving.
I want to offer my thoughts on these five points.

Point 1. I am happy to know when the ECF will deliver its report. We had been told to expect a report by the end of August, of course. I am concerned, however, that ECF “will report to the Vestry and Capital Campaign Committee.” Is there going to be a report available to parishioners? If there is, say, a PowerPoint presentation given by the ECF, will parishioners get to see it? Can parishioners attend the August 30 presentation? I have reason to believe the vestry intends to go into executive session to receive the report. Parishioners are paying for this report; they have a right to know exactly what it says.

Point 2. No one who has talked to parishioners about Fulfilling the Vision should be surprised by this admission.

Point 3. Like many parishioners last fall, I attended the first “visioning” meeting, but I did not participate in subsequent meetings. (I gather that few people did.) I had two reasons for not continuing to be a part of that process: (1) I thought the process was not well matched to our needs, and (2) it was never clear how the conclusions of the planning were to be used. That the proposed projects are tightly interconnected and part of a plan whose integrity would be destroyed by picking and choosing from among them is an assertion that has never been supported and which is not obviously true. At best, what the projects have in common is that they all came out of last year’s brainstorming (or dreaming). I will have more to say about this below.

Point 4. This assertion is designed to make us feel self-absorbed, shallow, and ignorant. One has only to look at the Statement of Operations on the facing page of The Messenger, however, to see that we are hardly spending an excessive amount of money on our physical plant. Of the $742,455 total budget, only $96,000 (just under 13%) is allocated to property. On the other hand, $506,815 (more than 68%) is dedicated to personnel expenses. In reality, we have continued to add staff while ignoring the needs of our aging building.

Point 5. The argument that we must add personnel to grow and that the increased giving from additional members will eventually pay for the expanded staff is an argument that, at best, has been only implicit until now. It is an argument that should have been made long before now. The argument is, alas, a highly questionable one, and I know cases where such a strategy has led to disaster. Lou assures us that “[i]t is a principle of congregational development that churches need to hire staff in order to grow, and that increased giving should follow.” I challenge him to cite an authority for this “principle of congregational development.” No one I consulted considered this conventional wisdom. No doubt, in some circumstances, additional staff could facilitate church growth. I don’t think, however, that any rule of thumb of church development justifies what has been proposed: adding 3 or 4 people, in addition to an expensive new service, all at once. Even if we had the money in hand to add so many people to the staff, it would likely be unwise to add them all at once, rather than expanding the staff gradually by adding one function at a time. This is not a rational investment in our parish; it is a reckless gamble. Also, I am surprised that, in the rush to add to the staff, no one has suggested adding a skilled technologically savvy communications person. Yet, improved communications is an often cited need at St. Paul’s, whose Web site is—not to put too fine a point on it—inadequate.

Thoughts on Vision 15


Vision 15 seems to be a laundry list of everything anyone thought it might be nice for St. Paul’s to have. Surprisingly, it did not include pony rides for the kids and a merry-go-round in the playground. Every church should dream, but planning requires adult supervision and the ability to focus on which needs are most urgent and which are either frivolous or of low priority. Fulfilling the Vision looks like the product of someone who could not say no to anything. Had I realized that what was being said last fall would be incorporated into an expensive fund-raising campaign, I might have attended more meetings.

As it was, I thought that the “appreciative inquiry” that began the visioning process was a poor technique for a St. Paul’s with a good deal of parishioner unrest. We were being asked to identify our strengths and how we could build on them. This is a fine task to undertake, but a more urgent task is to identify problems likely to impede our progress as a congregation. My impression is that serious problems do exist. At the very least, many parishioners believe there are serious problems at St. Paul’s, and the proposal of a grand plan to raise and spend more then $1.8 million has simply added to their discomfort about the health of our parish.

Sunday, August 1, 2010

Fulfilling the Vision, Part 7

My sixth post on Fulfilling the Vision is here.
I was surprised in church today when Lou suggested that the projects in the proposed Fulfilling the Vision package are all of a piece, relating to one as an integrated whole. Grab bagThis notion was a surprise to me and surely was to others, if they were paying attention.

The collection of projects appears to me to be a grab bag of everything anyone could dream up last year when people were brainstorming about what St. Paul’s could do. If all the pieces of Fulfilling the Vision are related, it isn’t obvious, and no one hitherto has made the case that they are. Why, for example, would Fulfilling the Vision be any less coherent if it contained no money for the endowment? for air conditioning? for the Blessed Mustard Seed Babies Home? I have no idea.

Many parishioners clearly think that the price tag on Fulfilling the Vision is too big. If the package is being offered on a take-it-or-leave-it basis, it is likely that the entire project will be rejected.

Sunday, July 18, 2010

Fulfilling the Vision, Part 6

My fifth post on Fulfilling the Vision is here. My seventh post is here.
One item in the Fulfilling the Vision proposal is $75,000 for a part-time musician assistant to Doug Starr. The primary duty of the person to be hired is support of the proposed Sunday evening Refuge service. (See my earlier posts here and here.) It is conceivable that this service could become a great success, but it is risky enterprise at a church with a recent poor track record of serving the needs of worshipers.

Before going to choir rehearsal this morning, I looked in on the 8:45 service. I counted 21 people in the pews—rather spread out from one another in a typical Episcopalian fashion, I might add—only one of whom was a child at this service that is supposed to be the “family service.” From my seat in the choir, I had a hard time getting an equivalent count at the 10:30 service, but there seem to have been about 65 worshipers in the pews. Additionally, lots more people were involved in putting on the 10:30 service; there were 22 choir members alone.

What is my point here? Simply put, I contend that the current 8:45 service is an unmitigated failure. People are avoiding it in droves.

Perhaps people don’t like the time of the early service. That seems unlikely. When St. Paul’s had an 8:30 and a 10:45 service, the services were similar, but the earlier service, like the present 8:45 service, was designed to be briefer. The concern of the church at that time was that the 10:45 service, despite its richer liturgical content, was attracting fewer and fewer worshipers, whereas attendance at the earlier service kept growing. The obvious conclusion is that a large number of parishioners prefer an earlier service. They also want a relatively mainstream Episcopal service, however, and they are willing to give up their time preference to avoid the band and eclecticism provided by the current early offering.

Why haven’t we given up on the disastrous experiment that is the present 8:45 service? Because, I suggest, this is the rector’s baby, and it is embarrassing to admit to having made a mistake. (In his defense, I should say that the rector may not believe he has made a mistake.)

What is worrisome is that the Refuge service is being initiated in the same way as the 8:45 service. The service does not come as the result of parishioner demand. The rector first brings in musicians to give us a glimpse of the coming attraction. He doesn’t ask what people think or try to achieve widespread buy-in. Instead, he forms a committee of supporters to plan the service and moves forward despite significant skepticism within the parish.

The questions about the Refuge service are legion:
  1. Are parishioners behind this service? I see no evidence of it.
  2. What are the competitors? (We’ve been told that there is nothing like this service in Pittsburgh. There are certainly services enough like it to be a threat, however. Where are they and how much of a threat are they? Television and sports may be a bigger threat, of course.)
  3. Where is the market research supporting Refuge? Who is the audience, and where is it coming from? How do we expect worshipers to get to St. Paul’s on a Sunday evening?
  4. Where is the cost-benefit analysis for the service? It may be unreasonable to expect the church to make Refuge into a profit center, but could the money spent on the service be put to better use? Could clergy time devoted to the service be put to better use? Apparently, we are doing a poor job of pastoral care—the proposed campaign looks to spend more money on that item—so perhaps the clergy time expended on Refuge would better be spent visiting parishioners in distress.
  5. What intended or unintended effects will Refuge have on St. Paul’s and on other Episcopal churches in the diocese?
  6. By what criteria will we conclude that Refuge is a success or failure? Judging from our experience with the 8:45 service, I suspect that the very existence of the service will be taken as a sign of its success.
Is St. Paul’s ready to invest $75,000 in Refuge? And make no mistake, there will be other visible and hidden costs of this service.